Published AP Ballots — 12 Verified Current-Season Polls

Reported Analysis · AP Men’s Basketball · Week 2

Memphis Beat Louisville by 20. The AP Poll Still Put Louisville Ahead.

Memphis remains outside the Top 25 despite appearing on more ballots than No. 25 LSU. Its split week and the placement of those votes explain the gap.

Poll Behavior graphic: Memphis won by 20. Louisville stayed ranked. Sunday: Memphis 98, Louisville 78. Monday: Louisville No. 23, Memphis unranked. An action photo shows a Memphis player driving against Rice, labeled archive February 2, 2025. Photo: 2C2K Photography, CC BY 2.0, cropped.

Memphis beat Louisville by 20 on Sunday, then watched the Cardinals keep a place in the AP Top 25 on Monday while the Tigers stayed outside it.

The November 16 poll puts Louisville at No. 23 with 263 points. Memphis has 172. At the cutoff, LSU takes No. 25 with 229 points, even though one more voter included Memphis than LSU.

There are two different arguments here: whether Sunday's result should put Memphis ahead of Louisville, and whether the Tigers did enough over the entire week to enter the rankings. The ballots show why neither question was settled by the number of voters willing to include Memphis.

The Win Was Convincing. The Week Was Complicated.

Memphis's 98–78 victory over Louisville included a 57–26 second half after the Cardinals led 52–41 at the break. This was a reversal large enough to put Louisville's ranking under scrutiny.

It also came five days after Memphis lost 105–81 at Vanderbilt. The Tigers finished the week with a decisive win over the previous No. 10 team and a decisive loss to the previous No. 22 team. Vanderbilt is now No. 15.

LSU supplied a different case. The Tigers beat Gonzaga 81–80 in Spokane on Saturday and reached 4–0. That made the final ranked spot a comparison between an unbeaten newcomer with a ranked win and a Memphis team whose latest result was much better than its first result of the week.

More Ballots, Fewer Points

Forty-two of the 59 voters ranked Memphis. Forty-one ranked LSU. LSU's advantage came from the positions attached to those selections.

AP scoring awards 25 points for first place, 24 for second and one for 25th. An unranked team gets zero. A name on a ballot therefore says something different from a name several places higher on that ballot.

Twenty-nine voters included both teams, and 17 of them placed LSU higher. Those ballots produced a combined 34-point edge for LSU. Twelve voters included LSU alone, contributing another 58 points; 13 included Memphis alone, contributing 35 to Memphis. Five ranked neither.

That accounts for the entire difference: LSU's 34-point edge on shared ballots, plus 58 on its exclusive ballots, minus Memphis's 35, equals 57.

Memphis's supporters placed it at an average of 21.90, compared with 20.41 for LSU among its supporters. Those averages describe different groups, but the complete scoring calculation reaches the same finding: Memphis had slightly broader inclusion and shallower placement.

The Louisville Result Is Harder to Dismiss

The Louisville comparison offers a more pointed challenge to the final order. Of the 30 voters who included both Louisville and Memphis, 21 put Memphis higher. Nine put Louisville higher.

Even in that group, Louisville finished with a net 21-point advantage because the nine voters favoring the Cardinals separated the teams by more places in total. Fourteen ballots included Louisville alone and 12 Memphis alone, adding another net 70 points to Louisville's lead. The complete margin was 91.

Those choices explain how the order happened; they do not make the head-to-head result disappear. Readers who give that result priority have a concrete reason to question Louisville's position. The broader comparison also has to account for Memphis's Vanderbilt loss rather than treating Sunday as its only game.

Memphis has a credible argument for inclusion without a clean claim to have settled the issue. The Vanderbilt loss keeps the week from being an uncomplicated endorsement, while the Louisville win makes a dismissal just as difficult. Its current support is broad enough to challenge the cutoff; what remains unsettled is whether those voters view the Tigers as a team safely inside the Top 25 or one barely worth a final-line mention.

Sources & Methodology

Analysis uses all 59 complete ballots in the November 16 men's Week 2 poll. Pairwise comparisons distinguish ballots including both teams, either team alone and neither. Unranked teams receive zero points and are never assigned a numeric rank. Conditional averages include only ballots ranking that team. Game dates, scores and venues are supported by the linked official recaps and Memphis's schedule. Poll positions referring to opponents in game context use the preceding November 9 edition. Submission times relative to Sunday's game are unavailable; this analysis makes no claim that a voter missed the result.

Poll Behavior graphic: Memphis won by 20. Louisville stayed ranked. Sunday: Memphis 98, Louisville 78. Monday: Louisville No. 23, Memphis unranked. An action photo shows a Memphis player driving against Rice, labeled archive February 2, 2025. Photo: 2C2K Photography, CC BY 2.0, cropped.

Download This Graphic

Memphis Won by 20. Louisville Stayed Ranked.

Graphic: Poll Behavior; archive photograph by 2C2K Photography. Source. Photograph: CC BY 2.0, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/. Original Poll Behavior layout and abstract generated texture; school marks remain with their respective owners.. Archive Memphis–Rice game photograph, February 2, 2025. Native crop and proportional scaling; does not depict the 2026 Louisville game. Background abstract texture generated with image_gen; no generated people or logos.

Archive photo (2025-02-02): 2C2K Photography. CC BY 2.0. Native crop and proportional scaling. No generated changes to people or uniforms.